Skip to content
Four rugby referee whistles, two with metal finger grips, on a blue banner

The Rugby Whistle: History, Famous Calls and How to Choose One

The rugby referee’s whistle is a New Zealand invention that a Birmingham toolmaker perfected. The first one blown in a rugby match was a sheepdog whistle in Canterbury, New Zealand in 1884; within eight years the game’s governing body had made a whistle compulsory, and the pea whistle Joseph Hudson launched that same year, the Acme Thunderer, is still what most rugby referees carry today. We sell the Thunderer in four models and talk to referees and coaches every week about which one to buy, so this guide covers the history, the calls that made whistles famous, and how to pick yours. Every whistle mentioned is in our Rugby Whistles collection.

Key takeaways

  • William Atack, a Christchurch journalist, refereed a match with a sheepdog whistle in 1884; the International Rugby Board made a whistle compulsory in 1892.
  • Joseph Hudson of Birmingham launched the Acme Thunderer, the first pea whistle, in 1884. The same family firm, Acme Whistles, still makes it.
  • One whistle, first used by Welsh-born referee Gil Evans in 1905, has started the opening match of every Rugby World Cup since 1987.
  • Pea whistles (Thunderer) give a referee a range of tones; pealess whistles (Fox 40, Acme Tornado) give maximum volume. Rugby referees mostly stay with the pea.
  • The Rugby Shop stocks the Acme Thunderer 560, 577, 59.5 and 477/58.5
  • Before the whistle: a referee with only a voice

In rugby’s first decades the referee had nothing but his voice. Two umpires, one from each side, carried sticks, and players appealed to them the way cricketers appeal for a wicket. If the referee needed to stop play he shouted over the crowd and the arguing.

1884: a sheepdog whistle in Christchurch

William Harrington Atack changed that. Born in England in 1857 and raised in Christchurch from the age of two, Atack was a Christ’s College scholar, a Canterbury cricketer and a journalist who later ran the New Zealand Press Association for 44 years. In 1884, refereeing a match in Canterbury, he found a sheepdog whistle in his pocket, asked both sides if he could use it, and blew it to stop play. The idea spread quickly.

The rules followed. In 1885 a Rugby Football Union circular in England laid down that each umpire must carry a stick and the referee must be provided with a whistle. In 1892 the International Rugby Board decreed that the referee must carry a whistle, and listed ten occasions on which it had to be blown. World Rugby’s laws still require it.

1884: Joseph Hudson and the first pea whistle

In the same year, on the other side of the world, a Birmingham toolmaker named Joseph Hudson solved a different problem. Hudson had set up J Hudson & Co in 1870 and had just won a contract to supply the Metropolitan Police after demonstrating his whistle at Scotland Yard; the “Metropolitan” replaced the policeman’s rattle. In 1884 he launched the Acme Thunderer, the first whistle with a pea inside, which produces the loud, trilling sound now inseparable from a referee’s call.

The Thunderer became the world’s best-selling whistle and the company, now Acme Whistles, still makes it in Birmingham’s Jewellery Quarter. Its registered designs include the Metropolitan (1884), the Acme (1886) and, after Hudson bought out rival maker De Courcy in 1927, the Thunderer trademark itself. The name “Acme” comes from the Greek for a high point, a nod to the whistle’s pitch.

The whistle that starts every Rugby World Cup

One Acme whistle has a career longer than any referee’s. Welsh-born referee Gil Evans used it for England’s first match against the touring New Zealand “Originals” at Crystal Palace on 2 December 1905, which New Zealand won 15-0 before a crowd reported at anywhere from 45,000 to 80,000, a record for rugby in England at the time; he then used it on the Springboks’ 1906 tour and the Wallabies’ 1908 tour. He later gave it to fellow Welshman Albert Freethy, who used it to referee the 1924 Olympic final in Paris, where the United States beat France, and the 1925 England v New Zealand match at Twickenham, where Freethy sent off All Black Cyril Brownlie, the first player ever ordered off in an international.

Nickel-plated Acme Thunderer rugby whistle with a black grip and silver-colored metal.

Freethy gave the whistle to All Blacks manager Stan Dean, and it was donated to the New Zealand Rugby Museum in Palmerston North when the museum opened in 1969. In 1987 it was used to start the first match of the first Rugby World Cup, and it has started the opening game of every tournament since, carried by referees from Bob Fordham in 1987 to Jaco Peyper in 2015. The “Freethy florin”, the coin tossed before the 1925 Twickenham match, travels with it.

Five whistles that changed rugby history

A whistle is only as famous as the decision behind it. These five are the ones referees still get asked about.

The Deans “try”, Cardiff, 16 December 1905. Scottish referee John Dallas, in street clothes and well behind play, ruled that All Black Bob Deans had been tackled short in the final minutes against Wales. Deans telegraphed the Daily Mail that he had grounded the ball six inches over the line and had been pulled back before the referee arrived. Wales won 3-0, the Originals’ only defeat of the tour, and a 120-year argument began.

The first sending-off, Twickenham, 1925. Albert Freethy, blowing the Gil Evans whistle, ordered All Black Cyril Brownlie from the field after seven minutes for kicking an England player, the first player sent off in an international. It took 42 years before another All Black, Colin Meads, was sent off, at Murrayfield in 1967.

The Haden dive, Cardiff, 1978. On 11 November 1978, with Wales leading 12-10 and minutes left, All Black locks Andy Haden and Frank Oliver fell out of a lineout as if pushed. English referee Roger Quittenton awarded a penalty, which he always maintained was for Geoff Wheel’s push on Oliver rather than Haden’s dive; Brian McKechnie kicked it and New Zealand won 13-12. It remains rugby’s reference point for simulation.

The forward pass, Cardiff, 2007. English referee Wayne Barnes missed a forward pass from Damien Traille to Freddie Michalak in the build-up to Yannick Jauzion’s try as France beat New Zealand 20-18 in the Rugby World Cup quarter-final, the All Blacks’ earliest ever exit. Barnes has since called it his most high-profile mistake.

The offside call, Twickenham, 2015. South African referee Craig Joubert penalised Scotland for offside in the final minute of the World Cup quarter-final against Australia; Bernard Foley kicked it and Australia won 35-34. World Rugby later said the decision was wrong, the first time it had publicly corrected a referee at a World Cup.

The lesson for anyone buying a whistle is that a referee’s authority comes from clarity. A whistle that players hear and read instantly is worth more than the loudest one on the market.

Pea or pealess: which whistle do rugby referees use?

Rugby referees overwhelmingly use a pea whistle, and the Acme Thunderer is the standard. A pea whistle has a small cork or synthetic ball inside the barrel that breaks the air stream and produces a trill; by varying breath pressure the referee can produce a short peep for a lineout, a longer blast for a penalty, and a sustained note for a try or the end of the match. Acme itself says pea whistles let rugby referees create a whole array of sounds to control the game, while its airfast (pealess) Tornado is the choice when sheer volume matters most.

Pealess whistles arrived in 1987 when Canadian basketball referee Ron Foxcroft launched the Fox 40, which uses chambers rather than a pea and cannot jam when wet or over-blown. They dominate basketball, hockey and football, and some rugby referees carry one as a backup. The trade-off is tone: a pealess whistle is one loud note, which is why rugby, with its culture of reading the referee by sound, has stayed with the Thunderer. Independent decibel tests put the loudest pealess models around 124 to 128 dB and the Acme Thunderer family somewhat lower, but still well above what any pitch needs.

How to choose a rugby whistle

Pick by three things: tone, grip and finish.

Model

Tone

Finish

Grip

Best for

Acme Thunderer 560

Higher, sharp

Symonite (polymer), matte black

Lanyard

Coaches, touch and youth referees, spare whistle

Acme Thunderer 577

Mid

Symonite, matte black

Finger grip

Referees who want hands free at the breakdown

Acme Thunderer 59.5

Deep, classic

Symonite, matte black

Lanyard

Senior club referees who want the traditional Thunderer tone without the cold metal

Acme Thunderer 477/58.5

Deep, classic

Nickel-plated brass

Finger grip

The referee’s whistle; the model most associated with rugby

Tone: the larger the barrel, the deeper the note. The 58.5 and 59.5 are the deep, authoritative Thunderer sound; the 560 is higher and cuts through on a windy touch field. If two matches run on adjoining pitches, pick a different tone from the other referee.

Grip: a finger grip (577, 477/58.5) keeps the whistle in your hand so you can signal and manage the breakdown without a lanyard swinging; many referees find it faster for advantage calls. A lanyard whistle is simpler and cheaper and works for coaches.

Finish: nickel-plated brass is the traditional referee’s whistle, heavier and colder in winter; Symonite polymer is lighter, does not freeze to the lip and does not corrode. Carry a spare whichever you choose; a lost pea or a cracked barrel ends a match.

Acme Thunderer Whistle - 477/58.5 - Nickel-Plated

Regular price $38.99
Sale price Regular price $0.00
View product

What the referees in our network carry

At The Rugby Shop, the Acme Thunderer Whistle - 477/58.5 leads the pack among match officials for its deep, commanding 115 dBA tone, while the matte black Acme Thunderer Symonite 560 and 59.5 remain popular everyday options for club coaches and touch judges. On the pitch, finger grips overwhelmingly beat neck lanyards for safety and instant access—preventing snagging in traffic while keeping the whistle poised between sprints. "I can't stand lanyards, always use a whistle with a finger grip," notes veteran community referee Craig T., adding that it frees his hands to signal advantage cleanly. For chilly Canadian autumn and spring kickoffs, seasoned officials avoid freezing bare metal to their lips by switching to matte Symonite plastic models or fitting rubber mouth guards over brass barrels, alongside keeping a pealess backup in their pocket in case condensation freezes a traditional cork pea mid-match.

Acme Thunderer Symonite Whistle - 560 - Matte Black

Regular price $13.99
Sale price Regular price $0.00
View product

Acme Thunderer Symonite Whistle - 59.5 - Matt Black

Regular price $24.99
Sale price Regular price $0.00
View product

Frequently asked questions

Who invented the referee’s whistle? Two people share the credit. William Atack of Christchurch was the first referee to use a whistle in a rugby match, a sheepdog whistle, in 1884. Joseph Hudson of Birmingham launched the Acme Thunderer, the first pea whistle made for sport, the same year.

What whistle do rugby referees use? Most rugby referees use an Acme Thunderer pea whistle, usually the finger-grip 58.5 or the lanyard 59.5, because the pea lets them vary the tone. Pealess whistles such as the Fox 40 are more common in basketball and hockey.

Is the whistle compulsory in rugby? Yes. The International Rugby Board made the whistle compulsory in 1892, and World Rugby’s laws still state that the referee must carry a whistle.

What is the Gil Evans whistle? An Acme whistle first used by Welsh-born referee Gil Evans for England v New Zealand in 1905, later used by Albert Freethy at the 1924 Olympics and the 1925 Brownlie sending-off, and now held by the New Zealand Rugby Museum. It has started the opening match of every Rugby World Cup since 1987.

Pea whistle or pealess whistle for rugby? Pea whistle for refereeing, because tone variation is part of how rugby referees communicate. A pealess whistle is a good coaching whistle and a sensible wet-weather backup.

How do I stop my whistle freezing to my lip in winter? Use a Symonite (polymer) Thunderer such as the 560, 577 or 59.5 rather than nickel-plated brass, and keep it inside your shirt between stoppages.

Blow the whistle

Whichever model you choose, you are carrying a design that has run rugby matches since 1884. Browse the Rugby Whistles collection, complete your kit from Referee Equipment, or contact us for referee society and club orders.

Leave A Comment